SCOTT D Miller - For the latest and greatest information on Feedback Informed Treatment

  • About
    • About Scott
    • Publications
  • Training and Consultation
  • Workshop Calendar
  • FIT Measures Licensing
  • FIT Software Tools
  • Online Store
  • Top Performance Blog
  • Contact Scott
info@scottdmiller.com 773.404.5130

Obesity Redux: The RFL Results and complex Nature of Truth and Science

August 28, 2012 By scottdm 2 Comments

Back in April, I blogged about research published by Ryan Sorrell on the use of feedback-informed treatment in a telephonically-divered weight management program.  The study, which appeared in the journal Disease Management*, not only found that the program and feedback led to weight loss, but also significant improvements in distress, health eating behaviors (70%), exercise (65%), and presenteeism on the job (64%)–the latter being critical to employers who were paying for the service.

Despite these results, the post garnered no attention until four months later during the first week of August when three clinicians posted comments on the very same day–that’s the beauty of the web, a long memory and an even longer reach.

What can I say?  I’m having to eat my hat (or, the bird on my shoulder is…).  I learned a great deal from the feedback:

  • Despite having sourced the figure from the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, the claim that weight gain due to poor diet and a lack of exercise was responsible for 300,000 deaths was false.  According to the comments, the figure is closer to 26,000, a mere 10% of the number claimed!
  • The same was true regarding the reported annual cost of obesity.  The 100 billion dollar figure reported on the AACAP website is, I was told, “grossly inflated” and worse, missed the point.  By focusing on BMI, the writer counseled, “we will have wasted money spent on the 51% of the healthy people who are deemed ‘unhealthy’ based on weight and the 18% unhealthy ones who are overlooked because their weight looks fine (see Wildman et al., 2008).”

Solid points both.  Thankfully, one of the writers noted what was supposed to have been the main point of the post; namely, ” the importance of “practice-based” evidence” in guiding service delivery, “making clear that finding the ‘right’ or ‘evidence-based’ approach for obesity (or any problem for that matter) is less important than finding out “what works” for each person in need of help.”

I want to make sure readers have access to the results of the study because they are an impressive demonstration of what’s possible when the feedback is sought from and used to guide service to people “in care.”  Weight loss aside, Ryan also reported significant improvements in distress, healthy eating behaviors (70%), exercise (65%), and presenteeism on the job (64%).  All this by using two simple, 4-question scales.

*Sorrell, R. (September, 2007).  Application of an Outcome-Directed Behavioral Modification Model for Obesity on a Telephonic, Web-based Platform.Disease Management, 10, Supplement 1, 23-26.

PS: An AP article that came out this last weekend and was discussed on NPR suggests the truth about the “weight of the nation” may be more complicated than either I or those who commented on my blog may realize.  Among the many changes that have occured over the last decades, the piece declares, “Who are we?  Fatter.  The average woman has gained 18 pounds since 1990, to 160 pounds; the average man is up 16 pounds, to 196.”   Hmm.

Filed Under: Feedback Informed Treatment - FIT, obesity Tagged With: American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Chronic Disease, cognitive-behavioral therapy, disease management, evidence based practice, icce, Weight Management

Comments

  1. Peter says

    August 29, 2012 at 1:28 pm

    This blog couldn’t have come at a better moment. I am about to go to a meeting to discuss a new program for weight reduction with folk from different disciplines.
    Criterium for inclusion: BMI higher than 30
    Process: exercise, diet and CBT techniques (the latter presumably by me)
    The only outcome criterium: relative weight loss and reduction of waist-size (measured by a nurse; talking about shame) at end of program and after 3 months.
    Thanks for the discussion; it has given me some relevant facts to bring into the meeting.

    Reply
  2. Christy says

    September 28, 2012 at 3:11 pm

    thanks for sharing, Scott!
    These are pretty good points
    p.s. love the parrot

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

SEARCH

Subscribe for updates from my blog.

  

Upcoming Training

 ICCE FIT Intensive Training with Dr. Scott Miller
ICCE FIT Supervision Intensive Online Scott D Miller

FIT Software tools

FIT Software tools

NREPP Certified

HTML tutorial

LinkedIn

Topics of Interest:

  • Behavioral Health (110)
  • behavioral health (4)
  • Brain-based Research (2)
  • CDOI (14)
  • Conferences and Training (67)
  • deliberate practice (27)
  • Dodo Verdict (9)
  • Drug and Alcohol (3)
  • evidence-based practice (65)
  • excellence (61)
  • Feedback (38)
  • Feedback Informed Treatment – FIT (203)
  • FIT (25)
  • FIT Software Tools (12)
  • ICCE (26)
  • Implementation (7)
  • medication adherence (3)
  • obesity (1)
  • PCOMS (11)
  • Practice Based Evidence (38)
  • PTSD (4)
  • Suicide (1)
  • supervision (1)
  • Termination (1)
  • Therapeutic Relationship (8)
  • Top Performance (39)

Recent Posts

  • Making Sense of Client Feedback
  • Umpires and Psychotherapists
  • Augmenting the Two-Dimensional Sensory Input of Online Psychotherapy
  • Death of a Friend
  • The Cost of Caring

Recent Comments

  • Asta on The Expert on Expertise: An Interview with K. Anders Ericsson
  • Michael McCarthy on Culture and Psychotherapy: What Does the Research Say?
  • Jim Reynolds on Culture and Psychotherapy: What Does the Research Say?
  • gloria sayler on Culture and Psychotherapy: What Does the Research Say?
  • Joseph Maizlish on Culture and Psychotherapy: What Does the Research Say?

Tags

addiction Alliance behavioral health brief therapy Carl Rogers CBT cdoi common factors conferences continuing education denmark evidence based medicine evidence based practice Evolution of Psychotherapy excellence feedback feedback informed treatment healthcare holland icce international center for cliniclal excellence medicine mental health meta-analysis Norway NREPP ors outcome measurement outcome rating scale post traumatic stress practice-based evidence psychology psychometrics psychotherapy psychotherapy networker public behavioral health randomized clinical trial SAMHSA session rating scale srs supershrinks sweden Therapist Effects therapy Training