SCOTT D Miller - For the latest and greatest information on Feedback Informed Treatment

  • About
    • About Scott
    • Publications
  • Training and Consultation
  • Workshop Calendar
  • FIT Measures Licensing
  • FIT Software Tools
  • Online Store
  • Top Performance Blog
  • Contact Scott
info@scottdmiller.com 773.404.5130

The Sounds of Silence: More on Research, Researchers, and the Media

July 21, 2014 By scottdm Leave a Comment

The Sound of Silence Flauta-1

Back in April, I blogged about an article that appeared in The Guardian, one of the U.K.’s largest daily newspapers.  Citing a single study published in Denmark, the authors boldly asserted, “The claim that all forms of psychotherapy are winners has been dealt a blow.”  Sure enough, that one study comparing CBT to psychoanalysis, found that CBT resulted in superior effects in the treatment of bulimia.

As I pointed out at the time, I was surprised that such an obscure research finding would be covered by a major newspaper.  “What could be the point?”  I wondered–that is, until I saw who had written the piece.  The authors were none other than psychologist Daniel Freemen, a strong proponent of the idea that certain treatments are better than others, and his journalist brother, Jason.

Jason&Daniel-Freeman

I have to admit, I suspected an agenda was at work.  After all, scientists have learned not to depend on extraordinary findings from single studies.  Replication is key to separating fact from hopeful fiction.  In the service of this objective, I cited a truly massive study published in Clinical Psychology Review.  Using the statistically rigorous method of meta-analysis, researchers reviewed results from 53 studies of psychological treatments for eating disorders.  The result?  No difference in effect between competing therapeutic approaches–a result confirming 50 years of robust research.  Why hadn’t this particular study been cited?  After all,  it was available at the time the two brothers wrote their piece.

Fast forward six months.  Another study from Denmark has been published, this one comparing two treatments for sexual abuse.  The results?   Both treatments worked and gains were maintained at 1 year follow up.  What’s more, consistent with the much-maligned “Dodo verdict,” no differences in outcome were found between analytic and systemic treatment approaches.

So far, no article from the Freemans.

Filed Under: Practice Based Evidence Tagged With: evidence based practice

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

SEARCH

Subscribe for updates from my blog.

loader

Email Address*

Name

Upcoming Training

Jun
21

FIT CAFÉ Summer 2022


Aug
01

FIT Implementation Intensive 2022


Aug
03

Feedback Informed Treatment (FIT) Intensive ONLINE

FIT Software tools

FIT Software tools

LinkedIn

Topics of Interest:

  • behavioral health (4)
  • Behavioral Health (112)
  • Brain-based Research (2)
  • CDOI (14)
  • Conferences and Training (67)
  • deliberate practice (31)
  • Dodo Verdict (9)
  • Drug and Alcohol (3)
  • evidence-based practice (66)
  • excellence (63)
  • Feedback (40)
  • Feedback Informed Treatment – FIT (218)
  • FIT (29)
  • FIT Software Tools (12)
  • ICCE (26)
  • Implementation (7)
  • medication adherence (3)
  • obesity (1)
  • PCOMS (11)
  • Practice Based Evidence (39)
  • PTSD (4)
  • Suicide (1)
  • supervision (1)
  • Termination (1)
  • Therapeutic Relationship (9)
  • Top Performance (40)

Recent Posts

  • Managing the next Pandemic
  • The Most Important Psychotherapy Book
  • Naïve, Purposeful, and Deliberate Practice? Only One Improves Outcomes
  • Study Shows FIT Improves Effectiveness by 25% BUT …
  • Seeing What Others Miss

Recent Comments

  • Jeffrey Von Glahn on The Most Important Psychotherapy Book
  • James Venneear on The Most Important Psychotherapy Book
  • Asta on The Expert on Expertise: An Interview with K. Anders Ericsson
  • Michael McCarthy on Culture and Psychotherapy: What Does the Research Say?
  • Jim Reynolds on Culture and Psychotherapy: What Does the Research Say?

Tags

addiction Alliance behavioral health brief therapy Carl Rogers CBT cdoi common factors conferences continuing education denmark evidence based medicine evidence based practice Evolution of Psychotherapy excellence feedback feedback informed treatment healthcare holland icce international center for cliniclal excellence medicine mental health meta-analysis Norway NREPP ors outcome measurement outcome rating scale post traumatic stress practice-based evidence psychology psychometrics psychotherapy psychotherapy networker public behavioral health randomized clinical trial SAMHSA session rating scale srs supershrinks sweden Therapist Effects therapy Training